#751: Mining Mount TBR – A Corpse Without a Clue (1944) by R.A.J. Walling

God, this was tedious.

Gentleman of indeterminate means an occupation Philip Tolefree — I don’t think I learned his first name until the very end of the book — is approached by two separate people who happen to have overlapping problems: an unidentified corpse in a London hotel who received one visitor (who various witness testimonies have as bearded, clean-shaven, and moustachioed) on the night he arrived and was found poisoned in the morning. Then, someone else is trying to find travel writer and possibly-perhaps-maybe something more Peter Palliser who has vanished on the very same night this corpse appeared.

The first quarter of the book is people telling each other this information over and over, and then Palliser turns up at the halfway point and a lot of elliptical dialogue is exchanged. Someone gets shot at, people run into the woods in pursuit of the shooter, more elliptical dialogue changes hands, and I lost the ability to care. It probably turns out to be one of those ‘international gangs’ stories, but nothing in the first half made me want to find out.


Well, okay, not nothing. There is a highly amusing Canon (“a huge man of forty with a thick thatch of dark hair and blue eyes twinkling out of a weather-beaten face”) who is tickled to bits to find himself consulted about his involvement on the fringes (“Can I tell my sister?” is all he wants to know when Tolefree first takes leave of him) and provides perhaps the one piece of enjoyment I found in the 100-some pages I managed. And, in fairness, on the few occasions Tolefree gets down to actual investigating, one or two good ideas do crop up (being able to establish for instance, the station at which a particular person boarded a train — that’s rather neat), but that and a few entertaining lines…

“If you dissected a newspaper editor, you’d find he had every organ of the normal human body except a heart. He’s got a large muscle distorted into the shape of a Query where his heart ought to be.”

…don’t add up to an interesting read. It is quite staggeringly pedestrian, with the central puzzle doubtless interesting in conception — I love an unidentified corpse, and can recommend some far better books revolving around them — but robbed of much intrigue on account of all the talking and talking and talking everyone does. It’s so blithely unconcerned with progressing its scheme more than half an inch at a time, and even then it wishes to go back and really examine that half an inch so you’re aware of what just happened. I’ve had enough repetition for one lifetime this week, thank-you, and I doubt this had a sufficiently exciting payoff to make it worthwhile.

“My word!”

Additionally, when it does seek to progress its story, it does so by simply baffling means. Palliser is known to have taken a train to a town out west, so Tolefree heads there. Palliser is also known to have links with a businessman, Frank Greene, who runs the water works in an adjacent town. Tolefree heads there. In this town, Tolefree gets talking to a pub landlord who mentions the water works and Tolefree says “Is that Mr. Greene’s company?” and the alndlord, who is apparently hiding Palliser — who is in turn in fear for his life from that gang I fully admit I’ve speculated into existence — panics, disappears from the bar for 20 minutes to warn Palliser that Someone Is On His Tail, and Palliser runs out of the pub and jumps on a bus to somewhere else.

And proves to be absurdly easy to follow, as it happens. Clearly whoever is after him isn’t that much of a threat, so why would you want to read more about them?

This was, apparently, Walling’s ante-penultimate book in a two decade career that saw him produce nearly 30 novels, and so, while we’re not quite in the Miles Burton/John Rhode degree of huffing the fumes of inspiration, I must give him the benefit of the doubt that he produced better elsewhere. Here, alas, he just seems to be trying a pale form of mimesis, mindful of what others have done elsewhere to great success and yet unable to recognise the ingredients that make such stories appealing fare. This is servile stuff, and unworthy of the time and attention of anyone who wishes to get something enjoyable out of the Golden Age.

Apologies for writing only half a review, but since I read only half the book, and since it’s about half as good as anything I’ve read in a long time, that’s all it deserves.


Over at The Grandest Game in the World, Nick has put together a precis of Walling’s career that implies he was better earlier and may have done some very good work. I’m inclined to believe this, because the alternative is that I find myself in agreement with Bill Pronzini and that…can’t be right.

15 thoughts on “#751: Mining Mount TBR – A Corpse Without a Clue (1944) by R.A.J. Walling

  1. This struck me with a question: what bad books are actually worth reading all the way through? Right? Because that’s the fear when abandoning a read – what if the end actually makes it worth it? Of course, we’ve done enough of these that we know when it’s not going to pay off in the end, but let’s loosen my premise a bit: what books were bad reads that contained a respectable conclusion?

    I had to search a bit before I thought of The French Powder Mystery and The Dutch Shoe Mystery by Ellery Queen. Both are stone cold dull, and would continue to be so even if you shaved off 70 pages. The French Powder Mystery somewhat redeems itself with a tense conclusion that sees thirty-some suspects whittled down to one (using logic that you could drive a truck through, mind you). The Dutch Shoe Mystery concludes with a misdirection worthy of John Dickson Carr, although again you get some flimsy logic in reaching it. Neither ending is worth the slog to get to it, but there’s something to be enjoyed nonetheless.


    • Well, The Red Right Hand by Joel Townsley Rogers might qualify — it’s hard yards, but the solution and the realisation of how densely the clues are packed in almost makes it worthwhile.

      See also:

      Cut-Throat by Christopher Bush
      The Blind barber by John Dickson Carr
      The Tokyo Zodiac Murders by Soji Shimada

      Doubtless others will occur to me in time…


  2. Walling represents one of those huge, gaping holes in my GAD reading and D, of Vintage Pop Fiction, also has some nice and encouraging write-ups of his 1930s mysteries on his blog. Black Heath reissued a whole slew of Walling’s novels last year with the most notable exception being his sole locked room mystery, Murder at the Keyhole. Typical!


    • This is also one of the Black Heath reissues ,though I picked it up in hardcover at some dim and distant point in the past for the exact reason you mention above — I’d not read him before.

      On form I can believe there would be something in his writing to enjoy, but I’m a) prone to enjoy books less on Kindle (or, well, I’m less likely to persevere with a book I’m not enjoying when it’s an ebook…and even that’s not quite right: the format really does affect my enjoyment) and b) thankfully rather over-blessed in the TBR department and so in no rush to jump into anything else by him just yet.

      I shall check out recommendations from others in due course, however, because I have this idea that there used to be these big rooms full of books one could go to and, in exchange for money, you would be allowed to take some of the books away with you and keep them forever. Am I right? Was that a thing? If it comes back, I want to be prepared…


  3. Man, that’s disappointing. I share your appreciation for unidentified corpses turning up where they have no business being so it’s a shame that something so full would be the result.
    Hope your next read is more to your tastes!


  4. Having read “Murder at the Keyhole” some time ago, the main thing I remember is that it has an interesting twist on the locked-room mystery, turning it in a sense inside-out. Apart from that it wasn’t outstanding, and was closer to a thriller than a detective story.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.