#330: Highs & Lows – Five Reading Highlights of 2017


January, month of rebirth and self-recrimination.  For every resolution to improve there must be some frank assessment of what debilitated you in the first place, and so the month can take on a curiously Jekyll-and-Hyde aspect for some.  So my Tuesday posts for this month will be a mixture of what is good and bad in my reading, and where better to start than a celebration of the previous 12 months?

I picked 5 topics, then spent ages trying to fit as much into each of them, and then sort of semi-abandoned the topics and we’ll just see what happens.  This is off to a good start, isn’t it?

1. Revelation of the Year

2017 will always be the year I remember for stumbling across just how much awesome contemporary work is being done in detective writing for younger readers.  Starting with the chance discovery (and subsequent interview) of Robin Stevens, then on via Sarah Rubin, and the excellent Mystery & Mayhem collection, expect much more of this in the year ahead — I already have titles by Katherine Woodfine, Karen M. McManus, Kim Slater, and Stuart Gibbs on my TBR, along with older mysteries from The Three Investigators and a few others up my sleeve, including some from the next category…


Plenty still to come…

2. Most Surprising Novel of the Year

No two ways about it, the rigour of the detection and analysis in The Mystery of the Invisible Thief (1950) by Enid Blyton blew me away.  I picked it up expecting some pompous, outdated, ginger-beer-sandwiches easily-disposed nonsense, and got…something rather more nuanced and considered.  I now have the entire Find-Outers collection, and shall very much look forward to seeing how the others compare.  Sure, they won’t have that same surprise value, but I can’t believe Invisible Thief would be the only one to approach its ideas in this way, and I’m excited to find out what else Blyton has up her hitherto-unsuspected sleeve.


Plenty still to come…

3. Translated Book of the Year

I don’t read enough translated fiction, but I managed to veer out into Norway, Germany, and some Scandinavian miserablism (I didn’t want to talk about that) beyond the Japanese and French delights brought my way by Locked Room International.  Two these are going to tie here — The Ginza Ghost by Keikichi Osaka for its ingeniously creative mash of utilitarianism and diaphanous framing, and The Madman’s Room by Paul Halter for spinning a tale so tight I’m surprised it didn’t garrote itself halfway through.

MR and GG

4. Detective Novel of the Year

Is it worth singling out a single book above all others?  Probably not.  Will it be entertaining to try?  Sure.  Some honourable mentions first, however:

The Burning Court by John Dickson Carr — If you haven’t read it, do so without consulting a single review, in as much ignorance of what the book is about as possible (don’t even read the back cover of my version, it gives everything away).  A book I’ve come to appreciate more the further I get from it, and one I will return to with immense curiosity in the years ahead.

You’ll Die Laughing by Bruce Elliott — Not a book I’ve seen reviewed or mentioned anywhere else, and one of my favourite discoveries of the year.  Simultaneously too ridiculous for words, perfectly logical, completely surprising, and oddly rather predictable, it’s one or two minor fixes away from being a masterpiece of the impossible crime genre.  No, I’m not kidding.

The Devil and the C.I.D. by E.C.R. Lorac — My second Lorac, and again a story that takes something simple and fills it out unshowily and with genuine intelligence.  I’m becoming more of a fan of the Dogged Police inspector than I am the Genius Amateur, I think, because the books are much harder to write well when you have to actually follow every single step.

Model for Murder by Derek Howe Smith — Part of the Derek Smith Omnibus, and such a delight in how lively and intelligent it felt given how moribund and ridiculous so many of the Sexton Blake stories I’ve read are.  Does something new with something very, very old and makes it work; so, of course, the idiots in charge of such things never published it.

Okay, no need to draw this out, the winner is:

The Sea Mystery

The Sea Mystery by Freeman Wills Crofts — Takes a simple idea and spins it out with such intelligence that I’d be inclined to make it mandatory reading in the genre.  Delicate, intricate, ingenious, and rich in pratically every single way there is.  Sure, the characters aren’t the most nuanced, but Crofts is a dullard?  Never!

5. Impossibility of the Year

A few stand-outs in this category — like the strangling of a man by The Vampire Tree, the impossible stabbing in Policeman in Armour, an unheralded delight from Soji Shimada — but two absolute belters put most other contenders in their place: one short story and one novel.

Realm of the ImpossibleThe first is from Rintaro Norizuki’s ‘The Lure of the Green Door’ in The Realm of the Impossible, which is — in my humble opinion — an impossible crime story on par with Carter Dickson’s ‘The House in Goblin Wood’ for sheer brilliance in plotting, clewing, and the general sense on mind-blowness you feel when it’s all made clear.  I enjoyed it even more because I had a different solution in mind, and one that was wildly inferior…so getting shown how wide of the mark I was delighted me doubly.

Murder on the WayThe second, and you’ll have to forgive my slight bias here, is the resolution offered at the end of Theodore Roscoe’s Murder on the Way! to explain away the root of all the chaos unleashed throughout.  It’s one of those all-too-rare moments as described about with the Norizuki story, that sense of having the bottom drop out of everything as certain actions from a undred pages earlier begin to realign and make so much sense, coupled with the surprise and the frustration at having missed it, then overwritten with the pure delight at having missed it.

Were I asked to indicate two examples from the last year of why my passion for impossible crimes runs so deep, these would unquestionably be the ones I’d reach for.


Okay, let’s end on that happy note. Come back next week when — yup — I’ll be sticking the boot into some of the crud I had to wade through last year.  What a time to be alive!

26 thoughts on “#330: Highs & Lows – Five Reading Highlights of 2017

    • Thanks, it’s always a bit daunting starting over again and wonderfing what lies ahead…but then I remember that January 1st is an arbitrary date and I technically do the same thing every time I finish a book and have to start another one. And I don’t know if this realisation makes me feel better or worse…


  1. I’m definitely picking up that Crofts today. And great to hear about the Blyton story. Do you know if she had a passion for detective fiction? Its always surprising to see when an author that you didn’t think could do it actually knocks it out of the park.


    • Absolutely no clue about Blyton’s predelictions or otherwise where detective fiction is concerned, but I’d be surprised if she hadn’t read at least a couple. And if she hadn’t, and she approached the genre entirely unschooled, then what she produced is even more amazing.


  2. I am particularly excited that your detective book of the year is sat up near the top of my TBR pile. Huzzah! Though you did recommend it to me so perhaps that shouldn’t be a surprise.
    On the topic of children’s mystery fiction, are you planning to read [SECRET SECRET SECRET]


  3. Some might raise an eyebrow at your most surprising revelation and novel of the year, but I can completely understand where you’re coming from. I was surprise myself when I began to read to The Three Investigator series and how good some of the plots/ideas were. Some even sported an impossible sub-plot! You can easily see how that series alone converted (some) children in the 1960, 70 and 80s into full-blown mystery readers. So you can also expect some reviews of classic juvenile mysteries on my blog. I have already hunted down a few titles. One of them takes place in my country.

    Seriously, I’m not surprised The Sea Mystery took the prize. You’re becoming quite a Freeman Wills Crofts fanboy. I recommend you read his excellent Mystery on the Channel this year. You’ll love it.


    • Well, if my most surprising revelation of 2017 came as a surprise to someone…that would be nicely fitting, eh? I’m not claiming that The Mystery of the Invisible Thief is a Carrian masterwork as a plot, but I was completely swept away with how fully Blyton applies herself to the detection — like, dude, how did no-one mention it?!

      Crofts continues to be a delight I thinnk he may even turn out to be one of those Christie-esque authors (for me) whose disappointing and dull books I will find a lot of enjoy in. That may not be correct, I may end up completely hating something on account of how narratively moribund it turns out to be, but I have my hopes — so much of what I like about him seems to be what others would miss or deliberately ignore (like, he’s funny!) so, yeah, I may’ve found me another keeper to go with Christie, Carr, Berrow, Penny, and others.

      Also, I realise I hadn’t told you: I was given a copy of Bruce Campbell’s Ken Holt mystery The Clue of the Phantom Car over Christmas, so I’ll be able to join your ranks in the analyses of those soon. Very much looking forward to it.


      • You have praised The Mystery of the Invisible Thief enough to justify hunting down a copy. You did your job!

        Interestingly, Adey practically missed every single pre-1990s juvenile impossible crime story I have stumbled across. The Mystery of the Whispering Mummy and The Mystery of the Shrinking House were published in the 1960-and 70s, but neither titles were listed. Same goes for Blython and Campbell.

        So can we safely state that the juvenile corner of the genre has been completely overlooked by everyone? Except by us, of course. We know how to sniff out a good detective story.

        And looking forward to your thoughts on The Clue of the Phantom Car!

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Thanks for the round-up, and I feel gratified that I own every novel you listed under your section on the best detective novel for the year. And believe it or not, I’ve not read any of these six novels! I’ve a few other Lorac titles bobbing their way to me on the sea.

    Perhaps I should dip into some of the YA mystery novels you mentioned. I’ve ‘First-class Murder’ awaiting me on the Kindle, but perhaps ‘London Eye Mystery’ and ‘Guggenheim Mystery’ might be better places to start?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.