#296: The Realm of the Impossible [ss] (2017) eds. John Pugmire and Brian Skupin – Week 1

Realm of the Impossible

As discussed previously, Tuesdays here on The Invisible Event will now pursue a particular theme each month, and throughout October I shall be looking at the new, multi-national short story collection The Realm of the Impossible (2017) from Locked Room International.

In stark contrast to other recent impossible crime collections this is pretty damn impressive in its scope: 26 stories from 20 countries, a lot of them appearing here in English for the first time or reprinted from the vaults where they have lingered forgotten for many a decade.  In addition, we also have 12 brief retellings of real life impossibilities from a range of countries and historical ages, from mysteriously-moving coffins to a classic impossible hanging, sometimes resolved and sometimes left unsolved.  We should take a moment to be extremely grateful for the work editors John Pugmire and Brian Skupin have done in getting this out — the logistics of this undertaking are phenomenal, and they’ve clearly put in more than a few metric tons of work to bring us something far from the ordinary.

BLBBoLRMI shall be tackling this by approximate grouping of countries each week.  Not only will this help give me a bit of a focus in how to approach the reading of this collection, it might also tease out some similarities and differences where different nationalities are involved.  And, besides, Otto Penzler already did the “grouping by impossibility type” thing in the superbly comprehensive The Black Lizard Book of Locked Room Mysteries (2014), and so this will hopefully prove to be legally distinct from that approach.  The other posts can be found here:

Week 2: Mainland Europe
Week 3: North Africa and the Middle East
Week 4: India, China, and Japan
Intermission: The Real Life Impossibilities
Week 5: Australia and the Americas

But for now, we’ll start with…

Week 1: The United Kingdom and Ireland

By pure coincidence, then, I start with two of the titans of Golden Age detective fiction.

First up — and republished here for the first time since its original appearance — is ‘Cyanide in the Sun’ (1958) by Christianna Brand, with its none-more-English setting of a seaside guest-house in holiday season and the slight complication of a series of seemingly random murders being committed in the vicinity over the preceding months.  Brand has, of course, a wonderful way with character and mood, and gives us gem after gem along the lines of

Her white, peevish face — powdered whiter than ever to attract sympathy for her purely imaginary ailments — was more peevish than ever.

When one of the guests at the above-mentioned establishment is poisoned in seemingly impossible circumstances we get a near-textbook exercise in how to increase stakes and suspicion without compromising on plot.  That more than a few character strands are left incomplete is actually a huge part of the charm, and it’s a suitably clever piece of authorly brinkmanship that sees the scheme revealed and justice done.  How this took so long to be anthologised is beyond me; it’s a great little story, and Brand is hardly an unknown…but, well, we have it now, and that’s what really matters.


“Darn tootin’!”

Next is ‘The Mystery of the Sleeping-Car Express’ (1921) by my new best friend Freeman Wills Crofts.  The setup here is the sort of gold we long for — two people shot on a train in circumstances that make it impossible for anyone else to be guilty and suicide excepted on account of a missing gun — added to the thoroughness we’ve come to expect from Crofts.  His exploration of possible solutions, all relayed in conversation rather than the doing (as in “We also did this…but it’s no good as an explanation because…”) is impressively entertaining and comprehensive, and the situation is sewn up perfectly, completely stumping the nameless investigators.

The difficulty for me is that the solution requires a very precise knowledge of the workings of early 20th century trains that I don’t possess…and I can’t believe too many other people around today do, either.  You’ll all prove me wrong by pointing out the basic thing I missed, I’m sure, but I read the explanation three times and am clearly missing something.  It sounds clever, that’s for sure, but this is more notable for its casual division of the British people into their respective ‘class’ compartments and the (honestly very interesting) workings of the train’s safety brake than the final revelation.  Still, it was his first ever short story, and it’s not like he didn’t improve from here.


This is in no way helpful.

Thirdly from these shores, and continuing the British obsession with railways and their workings, is ‘Sir Gilbert Murrell’s Picture’ (1905) from the pen of Victor L. Whitechurch, in which a carriage vanishes from a train mid-journey.  This being an early take on the genre, I personally feel it’s told the wrong way round — you’ll see what I mean when you read it — but there’s enough material here for the curious.  The solution becomes clear as you go, mainly because there only seems to be one answer to all of it, but the fascinating realisation of, say, the ignorance of key physical evidence on behalf of the police, or the manner in which a caller can be trusted to represent who they say they do, is a window on another time completely.

In contrast to the Crofts, there’s also technical information here that can be deduced from context even when not immediately obvious (aah, to feel smug because you’re paying attention…).  Interestingly, too, what both these stories do share is a lack of actual detection when it comes to the method: here as there we have the guilty party confessing the workings of their plot, and a moment of frank and brilliant trust from our villain in the detective which I’m still at a loss to explain.  So the whole thing works as a look at post-Victorian attitudes as well as a fun take on a problem that it’d be interesting to see updated.  And it has the distinction of the most incongruous final line of probably any short story ever.

Oh, wait, I’ve just remembered that this idea was updated in an episode of Sherlock and it was terrible.  This is a much better take on the problem, and maybe this is the ideal age in which to deploy it.


This might be the picture in question, but then again it might not…

Finally for this week, there’s ‘The Warder of the Door’ (1897) by famed duo L.T. Meade and Robert Eustace, a good old “family curse” story in which the impossbility turned out not to be at all what I was expecting: when the elderly patriarch dreams the location of a much-cursed tomb I imagined the nature of this dream would be the miracle exploded…but, not to be.  Instead we get the eponymous ghostly warder determined to trap our protagonists inside and the dream is left unexplained.  However, there is a lovely moment of confounded logic when — as with all the best curse stories — the precise wording comes under scrutiny…and, well, I’ll leave the payoff of that little adventure to you.

Meade and Eustace wrote some very atmospheric tales that have aged far better than Poe’s and should probably be more widely recognised, and this is one of them.  It is 120 years old, lest we forget, and while you can guess and the eventual direction, it and the others of theirs I have read show a degree of invention and innovation that the genre was lucky to have at this early stage.  They remind me of a more readable Maurice Leblanc, all gloomy atmosphere and weird conversational shifts but with rather more fun at the back of what they’re doing.  This, along with ‘The Mystery of the Circular Chamber’ that was included in Ye Olde Book of Locked Room Conundrums, will hopefully convince many others to investigate their work post-haste.

Ye Olde Book

Yup, I am shameless,

So, what do we learn about the UK from these stories?  Well, there’s a firm tradition of class-separation evident in the earlier three stories that has well and truly passed in time for Brand’s more grounded tale.  Where in one story an aristocrat is responsible for a crime he is shielded for no better reason than his position (or so it seems), whereas Brand brings the milieu down to a more relatable and more even field.  Maybe there’s more, and I’m sure someone less close to the attitudes exhibited here — I have spent my entire life surrounded by this, and it’s casting in such historical terms has formed a significant majority of my reading over the last 7 or 8 years — would pick out something more telling, but, well, I’m new to this insight lark and will hopefully have more to say as the settings and cultures become less familiar to me.


Next week: mainland Europe, with stories from Portugal, France, Italy, Greece, the Czech Republic, Germany, Finland, and Sweden.  Yeesh, I better get reading…!

15 thoughts on “#296: The Realm of the Impossible [ss] (2017) eds. John Pugmire and Brian Skupin – Week 1

    • The inclusion of the real-life impossibilities is inspiration enough — some of them are amazing, like the one on the French metro. And the fact that more than a few remain unresolved is definitely enough to get the brain working overtime…

      Liked by 2 people

  1. I’m very pleased at the growing number of locked room anthologies that have appeared in print over the past couple of years, but The Realm of the Impossible might turn out to be the all-time best in this category. So much original material and love the inclusion of real-life examples of impossible crimes. I dedicated several blog-posts to these pesky impossibilities that escaped from the printed page and hope, one or two of them, made it into this anthology.

    Anyway, I’ve to wait until later this month before I can pry this treasure trove open, but, until then, I welcome you whetting our appetite.

    P.S. You really, really should download and read Meade and Eustace’s A Master of Mysteries, JJ. The book is a legitimate landmark in the locked room sub-genre, which is a farewell to the secret passages of the 19th century and presaged the creative innovation that would come to define the genre during the 20th century. During the first half anyway. But it is a must read for locked room enthusiasts.

    Liked by 2 people

    • I know, I know, I really do need to get round to A Master of Mysteries…and Ed Hoch…and the rest of that Penzler anthology…and the remainder of the British Library Miraculous Mysteries collection…man, life is awful for the locked room enthusiast right now, hey?


  2. This sounds like an excellent compilation – looking forward to future instalments.
    The only one that I’ve read here is the Crofts one and whether the solution would work or not, I was drifting off by the end of it.


    • Mmm, yeah, it is a little dry. Still, give the guy some credit, he took on a legit impossibility for his first ever published story…no mean feat!


    • Very much so; there are a fair few storues here that whave been published elsewhere, but not for a long time in a lot of resepects, and a couple of the next batch are excerpts from longer novels that the average locked room reader would definitely overlook.

      It’s off to a good start, even if the start I’m off to isn’t the start many others will get (on account of, y’know, my not reading it in order. ‘Cos I’m such a rebel). Watch this space…!


      • Thanks Santosh. Also I needed to as you a question Santosh. What online resource do you use to read GAD stuff? I’m not sure where you are based but an Indian friend wants to read Carr and others and can’t seem to find any without spending huge amounts of money.


        • For books in public domain a very good resource is Internet Archive. For other books, Amazon India. Google Books is also a good resource for ebooks. Many copyright books are available for free borrowing from Open Library. For second hand books, a very good resource is Abe Books—-they ship to India (though delivery can take up to 2 months).
          I checked and find that several Carr books are available at moderate rates at Amazon India. Several Carr books are also available for free borrowing from Open Library.
          Of course, there are illegal resources also !

          Liked by 1 person

    • It’s not really section by section as they’re not arranged thus…it’s more just me finding a way to navigate it that makes sense to me…!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.