I was lured into Station by its format as much as its premise: a graphic novel telling a tale of murder on the International Space Station.
More than that, in fact; see if you can spot what convinced me I had to try this:
The International Space Station-the crowning achievement of mankind’s space program, assembled and maintained by the governments of the world’s five greatest superpowers…and the site of the ultimate locked-room mystery as one of seven astronauts aboard has targeted the others for death!
That’s not the first time I’ve seen “Locked Room Mystery” used in this context. The recent “Guess Who?” By Chris McGeorge, an entertaining piece of nonsense had exactly the same idea, six people locked in a room with a corpse that one of them had killed. Sometimes I think that blurb writers need a lesson or two in honesty. Note also the misuse of the words “mystery” and “like a modern day Agatha Christie”…
LikeLike
Yeah, that example did occur to me, as did Asa Avdic’s The Dying Game, which was certainly marleted in those terms pre-release (as TomCat will well remember — me and my stupidly believing what I’m told by marketing campaigns). It’s almost like that time “bad” got repurposed to mean “good” except with a less catchy soundtrack and now seemingly aimed at irritating me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, I remember. You were very naive not to see all the warning signs littering the plot description. And it was written by a Swede! You still believed them!
Anyway, I recently came across Mars Station Alpha by Stephen Penner, which is described as “A Locked Room Mystery in Space,” but seems to be just another science-fiction novel that resettled the story of the Lost Colony of Roanoke on Mars. I suppose it has some vague hints of Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None or Susanna Gregory’s short story “Ice Elation,” but I would be surprised if Mars Station Alpha even qualifies as a hybrid detective story – let alone actually turning out to be a locked room, or sealed planet, mystery. So… pretty much the same story as Station.
Yes, these marketing idiots need to learn the difference between a locked room mystery/impossible crime and a closed circle of suspects situation.
As an aside, one of thsse marketing idiots once described Jonathan Creek, a series of actual locked room mysteries solved by an amateur sleuth, as a supernatural cop show. Where do you even begin?
LikeLike
It is sort of amazing how wide of the mark some people can be. There’s a lot of subjectivity in reading and TV and fil, obviously, but things like genre were, I thought, generally pretty easy to pin down for the most part…that’s, like, the point of genre.
Still, I’ll wage my after-the-fact rage war on the publishing industry allowing these books to be mis-genre’d much to the consternation of a handful of nerds who — hey! — will buy the stuff ayway if they’re told it’s something they like. That, my friends, is marketing doing its job, after all…
LikeLike
I was at this really terrible party last night. There was no food I could eat, and everybody talked VERY LOUDLY! We were supposed to play cards, but we didn’t start playing for nearly three hours because our hostess had a story she wanted to tell us that took the whole time!!!
So your review brings great joy and relief, for several reasons:
1. When you suffer, we laugh.
2. You referenced one of my favorite scenes in early Hitchcock! Did you know that the director acknowledged making a terrible mistake with the end of that scene?
3. I learned about prosopagnosia! I had to look it up. Creepy!!!
4. I wasn’t at that party anymore!!!
5. I got to make a list.
Early Batman often featured classic whodunnits, although they were simplified for pre-teen boys. I have an 80-page giant full of these stories somewhere. I stopped reading comics before Batman got really good. I think Watchmen had a good whodunnit at its core. I also found a few issues of The Kindaichi Files at the local library and plan to read them one day.
LikeLike
What was the story about?
LikeLike
Her adoption. It wasn’t a bad story, just long!
LikeLike
I was at this really terrible party last night. There was no food I could eat, and everybody talked VERY LOUDLY! We were supposed to play cards, but we didn’t start playing for nearly three hours because our hostess had a story she wanted to tell us that took the whole time!!!
I thought you were describing the set-up to a GAD murder at first.
LikeLike
The Kindaichi Case Files are terrific! I’d recommend them to any GAD fan.
LikeLike
Agreed. Not as good as Detective Conan/Case Closed, but very good.
LikeLike